Tuesday, July 11, 2023

Spiritual Immaturity and the Ego-centric Self

 (Facebook post - 7/11/2023)

More of Rohr's wisdom along with some thoughts his wisdom stirred:

If our egos are still in charge, we will find a “disposable” person or group on which to project our problems. People who haven’t come to at least a minimal awareness of their own shadow side will always find someone else to hate, fear, and exclude. Hatred holds a group together much more quickly and easily than love and inclusivity.

Sadly, the history of violence and the history of religion are almost the same history. When religion remains at an immature level, it tends to create very violent people who ensconce themselves on the side of the good, the worthy, the pure, the saved. They project all their evil somewhere else and attack it over there. Someone has to be blamed, attacked, tortured, imprisoned, or killed. Sacrificial systems create religions and governments of exclusion and violence. Yet Jesus taught and modeled inclusivity and forgiveness!

As long as we try to deal with evil by some other means than forgiveness, we will keep projecting, fearing, and attacking it over there, instead of “gazing” on it within ourselves and weeping over it. The longer we gaze, the more we will see our own complicity in and profitability from the sin of others, even if it’s the satisfaction of feeling we are on higher moral ground.

ASL: Rohr's thinking stirs a couple of thoughts for me.

The spiritual journey involves recognizing and dying to the ego-centric self - that self we constructed, using what the world said we needed to do and be, in order to be accepted and valued by the world in which we live.

Our spiritual immaturity is evident in how we judge and condemn, reject and exclude others - any other. Our criticalness and exclusion are expressions of the ego-centric self's effort to prop itself up by comparing itself with others it deems wrong and thereby less significant. Their "wrong" translates into "I'm right" and "I'm better than."

The polarization within our country and within The UMC reflects this pattern of condemning and rejecting - indicators of emotional-relational-spiritual immaturity and a defended ego-centric self. In an era needing the best thinking of our mature selves, we are functioning out of immaturity. Immaturity is always evident in reactivity and anger, condemnation and judgement of others, rejection and exclusion, rigid positions supported by black-and-white, right-or-wrong thinking.

We have all experienced emotional wounds - generally in our formative years. Unrecognized, these wounds remain unaddressed. Unaddressed, they remain unresolved (unhealed). Unresolved, they shape our lives today, outside of our conscious awareness. They get projected onto others in the form of judging and criticizing, rejecting and excluding.

We constructed our ego-centric self in order to escape the pain of these deep emotional wounds - pain which we pushed deep inside beyond our conscious awareness. These wounds and their pain and the messages we attached to them are all dimensions of what Jung called our shadow.

The ego-centric self is fragile - a constructed self rather than an authentic self. It lives with strong defenses designed to protect its fragile identity, particularly its shadow. Criticizing and judging, rejecting and excluding others are some of its classic defense mechanisms. The ego-centric self lives by appearances - those things that project success and value: achievements, wealth, material things that wealth provides, the right circle of friends, the right groups, etc. The ego-centric self reacts to anything that gets too close to exposing its shadow. Thus, it is threatened by authentic spirituality. That's a major reason the religious leaders of Jesus's culture sought to have him killed. His teachings and actions undermined their merit-based world and its hierarchy, threatening their status and standing which they used to validate their ego-centric selves.

Healthy spiritual formation always leads us to address the shadow - those old wounds, their pain, the messages they produced, and the ego-centric self we constructed to deal with them. In other words, healthy spirituality involves healing - emotional-relational-spiritual healing. Sadly, in reaction to the Pentecostal movements and faith healers, the Western Church has abandoned the healing ministry. In its place, it has created an environment in which the ego-centric self can grow and flourish - a world centered on right beliefs, right behavior, right worship.

Immature spirituality - the realm of the ego-centric self - always produces positions that criticize and judge, reject and exclude those that are viewed as "other." It functions out of merit-based thinking. People are criticized and judged, rejected and excluded because they fail to measure up to some standard of expectations. Healthy spirituality always leads to inclusiveness that views and values, accepts and embraces every person as a beloved child of God. It functions out of grace-based thinking.

Before we are willing to deal with the ego-centric self, some kind of failure and pain are generally required. Such experiences strip away our self-deception, leading us to face our brokenness and need. That's where the grace of God becomes real and transformative.

This era in which the institutional church is dying could well be God's invitation for the Church to rediscover true discipleship - discipleship that involves dying to the ego-centric self. (See my latest book - Following Jesus: Discipleship in the Gospel of Mark.) 

Sunday, July 9, 2023

Reading the Bible Literally

When we first began to read the Bible, all of us read the Bible literally. It was the only way we knew how to read it. We naturally assumed it meant what it said, not realizing there could be more to the text than what it said. We do not learn to look for this “more” until we understand the nature of scripture—human and divine, ancient, Near Eastern, prescientific.

Reading the Bible literally opens the door to several unintended outcomes. It allows us to look for what we already believe rather than for what the Spirit would teach us. In turn, it allows us to use the Bible to validate what we already believe, thereby blocking our spiritual progress. Using the Bible to validate what we already believe, we are prone to use the Bible as a weapon against those who think differently. Arguing “The Bible says!” we block honest dialogue or any other possible understanding. In this way of reading the Bible, we pull verses out of context, ignoring the original meaning of the verses. In addition, we treat all texts as having equal authority rather than recognizing that some texts reflect a fuller understanding of God and the ways of God. The end result is spiritually damaging. We create God in our own image. We make ourselves the ultimate judge of truth. We create a me-centered spirituality that blocks healthy spirituality. We remain unchanged, stuck in old ways of thinking and living, spiritually blind and spiritually immature.

Reading the Bible literally makes us resistant to the work of the Spirit. One dimension of the work of the Spirit is to teach us spiritual truth—the things of God Jesus taught (John 14:26; 16:12–15). As a result, we learn to think differently. We move beyond the way the world trained us to think and live into thinking shaped by the character of God and the ways of God. The apostle Paul called this new way of thinking “the renewing of the mind” (Romans 12:2) and “the mind of Christ” (1 Corinthians 2:16). This renewing of the mind results in spiritual progress, a spiritually transformed life. In contrast to this life-transforming process, reading the Bible literally keeps us stuck in the ways we have always thought and lived, using the Bible to validate those ways.

A literal reading of the Bible is frequently presented as an expression of faith. While such a perspective is indeed an act of faith, it is a misplaced and misinformed faith. The true object of faith is God, not the Bible. The key question of faith is about God, not about the reliability of biblical facts: is God who Jesus revealed God to be as recorded in scripture? To view the Bible as beyond error (inerrant, infallible) also reflects a misinformed faith. It denies the human dimension of scripture while emphasizing only the divine dimension. It refuses to do the hard work of thinking and discerning that is an inherent part of interpreting the Bible.

(This post was first published as an appendix in my book Why the Bible Is So Hard to Understand … and tips to understanding it – Revised and Expanded Edition. The book is available on my website – pastorstevelangford.com – or from Trafford Publishing – Trafford.com - as well as from Amazon.)

Sunday, July 2, 2023

The Idolatry of Certainty on the Spiritual Journey

This blog is Part 2, i.e., a follow up, to last week’s blog: “The Issue of Authority in Discerning the Will of God.”

Underlying the many theological and ethical position statements made by different individual Christians and Christian groups throughout history is a certainty that their position is the right position because they can use the Bible to support it. Their position is “right” because it is “biblical.”

I argued in last week’s blog that this thinking is based upon faulty assumptions, a misunderstanding of the nature of the Bible, and a literal reading of the Bible. Jesus - as the fullest revelation of God, God’s character, and God’s ways – is the true guide to discerning the will of God, i.e., the “right” position on any theological or ethical issue. Such discernment is dependent upon “the renewing of the mind”, Romans 12:2, resulting in “the mind of Christ,” 2 Corinthians 2:16. Such thinking is thinking that has been shaped by the character of God and the ways of God under the guidance of the Spirit (1 Corinthians 2:7-16). “Be transformed by the renewing of your minds, so that you may discern what is the will of God – what is good and acceptable and perfect,” Romans 12:2 (emphasis added).

In this blog, I want to identify what seems to me to be the driving motivation for these “biblical” positions and statements of dogma. It seems to me that Christians who make these proclamations are seeking certainty – a clear sense about what is right and what is wrong, what is acceptable and what is not, what to believe as right and what to reject as wrong - and through that certainty, a sense of control.

Such certainty is a false idol on the spiritual journey which makes the quest for certainty nothing more than idolatry.

The quest for certainty is a quest for control. Certainty puts them in control, allowing them to define what is right and what is wrong, what is acceptable and what is not, what to believe as right and what to reject as wrong. Control is the reason behind the creation of any idol. Control is the objective of the certainty they project.

Those who hold to and argue for their “biblical” position generally reflect a rigidness in their thinking. Their thinking is right-and-wrong, black-and-white, either-or thinking. It has no room for nuances – the grey area that is inherent to any issue – or the messiness of the human condition. They want absolute certainty. Their arguments generally reflect a defensive tone, as though they are protecting the very foundations of their faith. If this position were to fall, the entire foundation of their faith experience would crumble beneath them. They have built their faith on the Bible being totally reliable – the infallible, inerrant word of God. “The Bible says” is their bottom line.

The rigid thinking and defensive posture of those who argue for their “biblical” position is revealing. It indicates fear, suggesting a deep-seated insecurity about their faith. Certainty is the façade they use to mask this insecurity, hiding it from themselves more than anyone else. Their unrecognized and unacknowledged insecurity is rooted in merit-based thinking. They have to know what is “right” so they can get it right. Unconsciously, their relationship with God is based on merit – getting it right, doing it right. Inevitably, such merit-based thinking and relating produces spiritual arrogance – “we are right, you are wrong.” It allows them to feel better than those who dare to disagree with them or challenge their beliefs. In my experience, certainty is always accompanied by a not-so-subtle spiritual arrogance.

While my description of these biblical literalists is harsh, let me hasten to acknowledge the commitment and sincerity of their faith, expressed in loyalty to their church and faithful involvement in the activities of their church – particularly Bible study.

Having acknowledged their faithfulness, I must also say that - in my thinking - the faith of these people is a misplaced faith. They have placed their faith in what men have taught them the Bible is – infallible and inerrant. (This teaching about the Bible and this language to describe it date to the late 19th century. It grew out of a reaction to German biblical scholarship that sought to identify the many sources that could be identified in the development of the Bible. The biblical scholarship of that time recognized the human dimension of scripture – as does biblical scholarship today. This discussion about the human dimension of scripture was seen by some – they called themselves “fundamentalists” - as a threat to the reliability of scripture. These fundamentalists argued that the Bible is a divine book, inspired (literally: God-breathed) by God and written under the guidance of the Spirit. As such, it is totally reliable. It is infallible and inerrant. In doing so, they opened the door to “biblical” positions, the spiritual arrogance associated with “biblical” positions, and to the idolatry of certainty. Their quest for certainty turned the Bible into an idol before whom they worshipped.)

The Bible is indeed a divine book. It is inspired – God-breathed, 2 Timothy 3:16. It is also a human book. God spoke through men and women who were moved by the Spirit, Hebrews 1:1-2; 2 Peter 1:19-21. In the Bible, we find both the human and the divine.

Given the Bible’s dual nature, is it reliable? Absolutely! The writer of 2 Timothy wrote it is “able to instruct you for salvation through faith in Christ Jesus,” 2 Timothy 3:15.  It “is useful for teaching, for reproof, for correction, and for training in righteousness,” 2 Timothy 3:16b. The writer of 2 Peter urged his readers to be attentive to scripture “as to a lamp shining in a dark place,” 2 Peter 1:19.

The Bible is a reliable source for helping us know God and the ways of God. It contains the stories of God’s self-revelation to and through the nation of Israel. Because God’s self-disclosure was accommodated to the people’s ability to understand at that particular stage of their spiritual development, it was always partial and limited – “in many and various ways,” Hebrews 1:1 - literally, “in bits and pieces.” This means some things in the Bible reflect the thinking and culture of the people at that period of time, not the will or ways of God.

So how are we to know which part of the Bible reflects the partial, limited understanding of Israel and which reflects God’s self-revelation?

Spoiler alert: discerning the will of God requires us to think. Specifically, it requires us to think with a renewed mind, Romans 12:2, and the mind of Christ, 1 Corinthians 2:16. Discerning the will of God is only possible through thinking shaped by the character of God and the ways of God.

God’s fullest self-revelation was in Jesus, the Son, who “is the reflection of God’s glory and the exact imprint of God’s very being,” Hebrews 1:3a. (The writer of Hebrews contrasted the full revelation of God through the Son with the partial, limited revelation given through the prophets, Hebrews 1:1-3. Also see John 1:14, 16; John 14:8-9a; Colossians 1:15, 19; 2:9.)  

Because Jesus is the fullest revelation of God, we know the character of God. “God is love,” 1 John 4:8. God is “merciful and gracious, slow to anger, and abounding in steadfast love and faithfulness, keeping steadfast love for the thousandth generation, forgiving iniquity, wickedness, and sin,” Exodus 34:6-7. In his letter to the Romans, Paul spoke of this steadfast, faithful love as “the righteousness of God,” Romans 1:16-17; 8:28-39. In addition, because of Jesus, we know the ways of God. God relates to us out of grace and forgiveness, freely embracing us as beloved children – Ephesians 1:3-5; 2:4-10, 13-22; 1 John 3:1-3. God uses the divine power to serve, Mark 9:33-35; 10:41-44; Philippians 2:5-11, advocating for and empowering the powerless (justice), Isaiah 1:17.

We know these things about God – the character of God, the grace-based ways of God – by faith! We have faith that God is who Jesus revealed God to be. Paul spoke of “the knowledge of the glory of God in the face of Jesus Christ,” 2 Corinthians 4:6c. Paul means that, in Jesus, we know what God is like – the glory of God. Our knowing, however, is an act of faith. Paul went on to say “we walk by faith, not by sight,” 2 Corinthians 5:7.

Our faith gives us confidence, 2 Corinthians 5:6 and 8, but not certainty. We are confident in who God is and in the ways of God because of Jesus. Everything else - what is right and what is wrong, what is acceptable and what is not, what to believe as right and what to reject as wrong – must be judged in light of the life and teachings of Jesus. We discern the will of God by exploring the life and teachings of Jesus under the guidance of the Spirit. Such exploration – an act of faith - helps us align our thinking and thereby our living with the character of God and the ways of God - again, an act of faith.

Faith expressed in confidence - not certainty - is the mark of a follower of Jesus. I am confident that God is who Jesus revealed God to be. Faith is also expressed in a teachable spirit. Faith keeps us open and teachable, willing to learn and grow and change, again the mark of a follower of Jesus, while certainty produces a closed mind that is unwilling to learn and grow. (Remember: the transformation of our lives comes through the renewing of the mind, i.e., learning, Romans 12:2.) Faith is expressed in humility. Humility, not the arrogance that accompanies certainty, is the mark of a teachable spirit.

I want to say “I am certain that I am right about this,” but in light of what I’ve written, I’d better say, “I’m confident that this way of thinking aligns with what it means to live by faith.” Living out of the confidence I have in this way of thinking is an act of faith – just as the certainty of some is an expression of their faith. The difference between my faith and their faith is the object of our faith – and that makes all the difference in the world.  

Sunday, June 25, 2023

The Issue of Authority in Discerning the Will of God

It’s something Christians – as individuals and as groups – have done since the church first began at Pentecost. We make declarations about what is right and what is wrong, what is acceptable and what is not, what to believe as right and what to reject as wrong. We make these declarations with certainty, generally grounding them in what the Bible says. These declarations, by nature, call for agreement and conformity. Sadly, they almost always create the opposite: disagreement and division.

The earliest example of this practice was the attitude and position of the early church regarding Gentiles. Following the teachings of their Jewish heritage, the early Christians viewed Gentiles as unclean. As a result, Gentiles were excluded from the church, rejected as unacceptable. Acts 10 and 11 records how the Spirit led Peter and, through him, those early believers to a different understanding. That different understanding resulted in the embrace of Gentiles as fellow-believers and their inclusion in the church. This shift in position was not embraced by everyone. Many insisted the Gentiles had to become Jews and follow the law in order to become Christians. The conflict led to a council held in Jerusalem to resolve the issue, Acts 15. The council made a decision that opened the door to the Gentiles.

The most recent example of this practice was the declaration by Southern Baptists that women are not permitted to preach or be pastors. In Methodist life, the splintering of The UMC and the creation of the Global Methodist Church are the result of a fifty-year conflict over a statement in The Book of Discipline declaring homosexuality to be incompatible with biblical teachings. Consequently, homosexuals who lived in an open homosexual relationship are not eligible for ordination, UM clergy are not permitted to perform homosexual weddings, and UM properties are not available for homosexual weddings.

The early church’s shift in position regarding Gentiles serves as a reminder. Some positions, even though based on religious teaching and tradition, can be wrong. New understanding moves us to set them aside as wrong and invalid. The church’s attitude toward slavery is one example. Some United Methodists would say the condemnation of homosexuality is another.

These declarations stating a position regarding belief and practice almost always appeal to scripture. Scripture is viewed as authoritative and the final word regarding the matter. Thus, the position is presented as “the biblical position.”

The appeal to scripture is based on several generally unexamined assumptions. It assumes the Bible is a source book for determining what is right and what is wrong, what is acceptable and what is not, what to believe as right and what to reject as wrong – in other words, a rule book to be followed. It assumes the teachings found in scripture reflects the will of God. It assumes the teachings are correct and unchanging (i.e., the Bible is infallible and inerrant). As such, the Bible’s teaching reflects the only acceptable position. The appeal to scripture assumes there is one, unchanging position expressed throughout scripture. It assumes the issue in question is a simple black-and-white, either-or position. The appeal to scripture attributes equal authority to every verse regardless of the time period out of which the text came or its location in scripture. It assumes a literal reading of scripture is the only way to read scripture, i.e., the right way. It assumes any approach to scripture based on biblical scholarship is intended to undermine the teaching of scripture and is thus to be rejected.

These assumptions overlook the human dimension of scripture – the historical, cultural context out of which the text arose. As a result, a cultural belief is treated as an eternal truth applicable to every culture and time, i.e., women speaking in church, 1 Corinthians 14:33b-36. These assumptions ignore what the New Testament writers said about the partial, incomplete nature of their scriptures – our Old Testament. See Hebrews 1:1. These assumptions do not acknowledge the progression of understanding reflected in scripture. For example, the law of Moses attempted to temper the unlimited retaliation of Lamech (Genesis 4:23-24) with limited retaliation (Leviticus 24:17-22). Jesus went beyond the law of Moses to nonretaliation (Luke 6:27-36) and unlimited forgiveness (Matthew 18:21-35). These assumptions do not deal with how different texts challenge and refute positions expressed in other texts. For example, the books of Jonah and Ruth were written to challenge the ethnic cleansing under Ezra. The book of Job challenged the theology known as divine retribution (God rewards the righteous and punishes the wicked) found in the book of Proverbs and some of the Psalms. These assumptions do not acknowledge the New Testament position that the fullest revelation of God and the ways of God is in Jesus - John 1:14, 18; John 14:8-9; Hebrews 1:3; Colossians 1:15, 19.

Perhaps the greatest drawback to these assumptions is they allow the reader to pick and choose which texts to focus upon, ignoring other texts that might present a different understanding. They allow the reader to use the Bible to support what they already believe. In other words, these assumptions make what the reader already thinks to be the ultimate authority, not the Bible.

The apostle Paul wrote about how to know the will of God – “what is good and acceptable and perfect,” Romans 12:2c. According to Paul, knowing God’s will grows out of the “renewing of your minds,” Romans 12:2b. As our thinking begins to be shaped by the character of God and the ways of God (as opposed to how the world trained us to think – “stop being conformed to this world,” Romans 12:2a), we will be able to discern the will of God. Thinking shaped by the Spirit – what Paul called “the mind of Christ,” 1 Corinthians 2:16 – positions us to know and live in harmony with the will of God. See again 1 Corinthians 2:7-16.


In short, the Bible is not the final authority to be used in determining the will of God. Jesus is. Our appeal is to Jesus – his teachings, what he did and didn’t do, his life and ministry – not the Bible. In seeking to determine God’s will, we should ask “Is it Christ-like?”, not “is it biblical?” Only a transformed mind can help us answer recognize the difference in the two questions. Only a transformed mind can help us answer the question “Is it Christ-like?” 

Saturday, June 17, 2023

Misreading the Bible

I’m not really surprised. In fact, if I had thought about it, I would have seen it coming. It was predictable.

This past week, the Southern Baptist Convention – the national body of Southern Baptist churches – overwhelmingly adopted a position statement that excluded women from preaching or from serving as pastors. In their reading of the Bible, only men are qualified to serve in these leadership roles. In this same decision-making meeting, they voted to “withdraw fellowship” from (i.e., not live in a cooperative relationship with) churches that went against this policy and ordained women to serve as pastors.

As you might imagine, I am deeply saddened by this news. In my opinion, this decision goes against Southern Baptist polity, theology, and the teaching of scripture. (In case you don’t know or it slipped your mind, I grew up in a Southern Baptist church, identified God’s call on my life in that church, and was educated – three theological degrees – in Southern Baptist schools. I served as a pastor of three different Southern Baptist congregations before moving into The UMC. In my mind, this history qualifies me to speak to the issue even though I no longer identify as a Southern Baptist.)

The decision to exclude women from the ministry of preaching goes against their own polity. In Southern Baptist life, each local church is autonomous. That is, no governing body or person (bishop) can dictate to them what to believe or how to function. They are self-governing, including selecting their own pastors. This decision by the national body violates the autonomy of every local Southern Baptist church.

The decision to exclude women from the ministry of preaching goes against their own theology. One of the beliefs that is foundational in Baptist history is known as “the priesthood of every believer.” The autonomy of each local church is built upon this theological understanding. The priesthood of every believer asserts that every believer can relate directly to God through the priesthood of Jesus (the book of Hebrews). A human priest is not needed as a go-between with God. A corollary is every believer is capable, under the guidance of the Holy Spirit, of understanding spiritual truth found in scripture. In other words, understanding the Bible is not dependent on a specially trained scholar. (I would hasten to add that a trained scholar can help us better understand the Bible. Without the benefit of education and training in how to read/study the Bible, we are prone to misread the Bible.)

Which brings me to my third observation: the decision to exclude women from the ministry of preaching goes against the teachings of scripture. The New Testament has numerous references to women who preached and served as pastors. The first to proclaim the good news of Jesus’s resurrection were women. Mary Magdalene was the apostle to the apostles. Philip the evangelist had four daughters “who prophesied,” i.e., preached, Acts 21:9. The apostle Paul commended Phoebe the deacon and urged the churches of Rome to aid her in her ministry, Romans 16:1. Part of her role was to read and interpret Paul’s letter to those churches. In other words, she was to teach and preach on Paul’s behalf. Paul also greeted Prisca or Priscilla, Romans 16:3. She is listed before her husband Aquila because she was the pastor of the church that met in their home, Romans 16:5. She also instructed Apollos as he began his ministry, Acts 18:24-28. In 1 Corinthians 12, Paul taught about the gifts of the Spirit. The gift of prophecy or preaching was one of the spiritual gifts he identified. Nowhere in the chapter does he suggest that some gifts were for men and others were for women. Rather, he said the Spirit “allots to each one individually just as the Spirit chooses,” 1 Corinthians 12:11. In a patriarchal culture, women were a part of Jesus’s disciples along with the twelve, Luke 8:1-3.

At the beginning of this blog, I said the decision by Southern Baptists to exclude women from the ministry of preaching was predictable. It is the natural outcome of decisions made in the late 1970’s and 1980’s. During that period of Southern Baptist history, a group of conservative leaders (I call them fundamentalists) orchestrated and implemented a plan to gain control over all Southern Baptist schools and institutions. Their efforts were motivated by the belief that seminary professors had become too liberal in their thinking. The intent of their efforts was to weed out those liberal professors and restore what they considered to be orthodox teaching. That orthodox teaching was grounded in the belief that the Bible is inerrant and infallible. It was intended to be read and understood literally.

Reading the Bible literally, viewing it as infallible and inerrant, almost always results in misreading of the Bible. That approach allows us to read our understanding into scripture, using the Bible to support what we already think. (When we use the Bible to support what we already think, we resist the Spirit-guided “renewing of the mind” that is foundational to spiritual growth, Romans 12:2. We create God in our own image.) This approach treats every verse with equal authority although the Bible itself clearly states that the Hebrew Scriptures (what we call the Old Testament) only provides incomplete, partial glimpses of God and the ways of God, Hebrews 1:1-3. (The original that is translated as “in many and various ways,” Hebrews 1:1 carries the idea of “in bits and pieces.”) The New Testament states that Jesus is the fullest, clearest revelation of God, Hebrews 1:3, John 1:14, 16; 14:8-9. Consequently, we are to read and interpret the Bible through the lens of Jesus’s life, ministry, and teachings.

A literal, non-scholarly reading and interpretation of scripture produced the decision to exclude women from the ministry of preaching and/or being a pastor. The decision is the result of reading scripture through the lens of a patriarchal culture rather than through the lens of biblical scholarship. In my opinion, the decision is the result of misreading the Bible.

While the decision by Southern Baptists may seem to be irrelevant to many who read this blog, I would hasten to remind you that the same dynamics have been at play in The UMC. A literal reading of scripture, viewing it as infallible and inerrant and thus rejecting the teachings of trained biblical scholars, has led to the judgment and exclusion of LGBTQ+ people in United Methodist life.

Saturday, June 10, 2023

The Trinity Plus One: Joining the Dance

In last week’s blog – The Mystery of the Three-in-One – I spoke of the relationship shared among the Father, Son, and Spirit as a dance of self-giving, other-focused love. Their shared character of self-giving, servant love makes them one. The three live in unity rooted in their shared character.

Living out of their character of self-giving love, each is focused on the good of the other. They escape the trap we humans inherently experience, the trap of being self-focused and self-serving, i.e., being ego-centric. As I said last week, their dance of love is life-giving and joy-filled. It led to the creation of us humans in their divine likeness. We were created to live in relationship with the Trinity. We were created to participate in their life of self-giving love. We were created to possess their character of self-giving love as our own.

Each member of the Godhead has given their divine Self to bring us to the emotional-relational-spiritual maturity of possessing their divine character as our own. God the Father has chosen us to be holy and blameless, adopting us as beloved children, Ephesians 1:3-5. Through Jesus the Son, the Father’s plan for us becomes reality, Ephesians 1:7-12. We experience redemption, the forgiveness of our sins. Though dead in our trespasses and sins, God makes us alive again through Christ, Ephesians 2:1-5. We have been raised with Christ and are seated with him in the heavenly realms, Ephesians 2:6. We are Exhibit A of the greatness of God’s grace and mercy, Ephesians 2:7. As God’s beloved children, we receive an inheritance from God that consists of “every spiritual blessing in the heavenly realms, Ephesians 1:11, 3. We become God’s partners in God’s eternal redemptive purpose of restoring unity to all of creation under the Lordship of Jesus – “so that we, who were the first to set our hope on Christ, might live for the praise of his glory”, Ephesians 1:12. The Spirit has given the divine Self to bring into reality all that the Father purposed and Jesus made possible, Ephesians 1:13-14. The Spirit marks us as beloved children of God and is the guarantee (the Greek term means down payment, earnest money) from the Godhead that before they are through, we will have been conformed to the likeness of Christ – “to maturity, to the measure of the full stature of Christ,” Ephesians 4:13.

In short, we have been invited to join the dance of the Trinity – the dance of self-giving, other-centered love. We have been invited to share their life. We have been invited to experience their life-giving, joy-filled life as our own. We have been invited to be their partners in their eternal redemptive purpose. We have been invited to be the fourth member of the Trinity plus One.

The place we practice and perfect the Trinity’s dance of love is in spiritual community, i.e., the church. Like the Trinity, the church was created to live out of “unity in diversity, resulting in community.” In the spiritual community known as the church, every person has a place – after all, belonging is based on God’s grace and forgiveness, not on qualifying by measuring up to some prescribed standard of belief, behavior (morals), or church involvement. Every person has value. Every person has a contribution to make – at least, that’s what Paul argues in 1 Corinthians 12.

The key to dancing together in unity is growing into Christ-like maturity in which we love as Jesus loved, 1 Corinthians 13. As long as we live out of our ego-centric, self-focused, self-serving default nature, we will divide ourselves into us-them groups and miss the dance. Only the Spirit can empower us to dance in step together, living together in unity and oneness like the Godhead.

“I therefore, the prisoner of the Lord, beg you to lead a life worthy of the calling to which you have been called, with all humility and gentleness, with patience, bearing with one another in love, making every effort to maintain the unity of the Spirit in the bond of peace,” Ephesians 4:1-3 (emphasis added).  

Come, let’s dance together in the unity of the Spirit. Let’s join the life-giving, joy-filled dance of the Trinity. Let’s do the dance of self-giving love – through the power of the Spirit! 

Saturday, June 3, 2023

Trinity Sunday, 2023 - The Mystery of the Three-in-One

Trinity Sunday – the Sunday following Pentecost Sunday - is an often-overlooked Sunday in the liturgical calendar. Perhaps it is overlooked because we are baffled by the mystery of the Trinity.

How are we to understand the mystery of the Trinity – the three-in-one? God is three yet one!? How can that be? We can’t figure out how to wrap our minds around the idea.

Perhaps the problem is in our language.

Trinity refers three. We speak of God as Father, the creator, and of Jesus the Son who was God-in-the-flesh and of the Spirit who was poured out on the disciples at Pentecost. We find references to each in the teachings of Jesus (particularly John 14-17) and in the writings of Paul (e.g., Romans 8, 1 Corinthians 2, Galatians 5). Ephesians 1:3-14 identifies the role each plays in God’s eternal redemptive purpose (Ephesians 1:3-6, the role of God the Father; 1:7-12, the role of the Son, 1:13-14, the role of the Spirit). These references indicate the concept of God as three-in-one developed during the early New Testament era.

Our trouble begins with the word “one.” Because we think of trinity in numerical terms, i.e., three, we naturally think of one in numerical terms. The term “one” does not refer to a numerical value. Rather, it refers to a relationship. More specifically, it refers to a kind of and quality of relationship.

The three live together in a relationship marked by oneness. Another way of expressing the idea is that the three live together in unity. The theological term used to describe the Trinity is “unity in diversity, expressed in community.” Unity or oneness is what is meant by the term one. Diversity refers to the three – each unique and different, yet bound inseparably together in unity and oneness.

That which binds the three together as one is their shared character of self-giving love. As the author of 1 John wrote, “God is love,” 1 John 4:8. The character of God the Father is that of self-giving love as is the character of the Son as is the character of the Spirit.

Because of their mutual character, the three members of the Godhead live together in a dance of other-focused love. (The early church fathers used the Greek word for dance to speak of the relationship of the Godhead.) Their dance is life-giving and joy-filled. Their dance is what led to the creation of the world and of us humans made in their likeness. We were created as an act of love. We were created to live in relationship with them and thereby to participate in their dance of love. We were created with the capacity to share their character of self-giving love and, thereby, to participate in their quality of life. In keeping with their character, each has given themselves to grow us in the likeness of Christ, empowering us to love as they love.

In John 17, Jesus prayed that we, his followers, would be one “as we are one,” John 17:11. Our oneness as his followers is patterned after and reflects the oneness of the Godhead – a oneness of character, a oneness of love.

The Trinity – the three-in-one – is not a mystery to be understood and explained. Rather, it points us to a relationship from which we came and for which we were created – a relationship governed by the self-giving love of God - Father, Son and Holy Spirit.

May we join the life-giving, joy-filled dance of the three-in-one as we grow in and live out of the likeness of Christ.

Reflections from Worship Today

  As I participated in corporate worship today, a question came to me: “does what we do in corporate worship keep us stuck in spiritual imma...