Sunday, October 15, 2023

Our Ugly Underbelly

We saw it again this past week—the ugly underbelly of our human nature. We like to ignore it, pretending it is not there. Then it surfaces in ways that strip us of our self-deluding pretense, in ways that no longer allow us to deny its reality—like it did this past week in the Hamas-led attack against the villages in southern Israel.

People around the world were caught up in a whirlwind of emotions and reactions at the atrocities that were committed against Israeli citizens—men and women, children, infants, young adults at a music festival, the elderly. Some were quick to condemn while others danced with joy in the streets. Many reacted with horror, appalled by what they saw and heard, describing it as evil. Not-this-again dread and fear stirred in the hearts of Jewish people all over the world.

Of course, many were quick to lay blame at the feet of one group or another—Hamas, Israel, Iran, the US, Biden, the Democrats, the dysfunction of the U.S. House of Representatives, some present-day Axis of Evil. Their words of accusation reflect their own alliances and loyalties and priorities, not necessarily reality.

We may never know the deep, festering cesspool of motives behind the attack or the complex network of alliances that planned and financed it. Few of us can understand the convoluted historical, political context which produced and fuels the seemingly unending, life-threatening tension between the Israeli and Palestinian peoples.

As with our experience of 9/11, people are dividing into us-them groups. The focus is on “the other.” Blame is attributed to “them.” “The other” is being demonized, robbed of their humanity. One Israeli leader spoke of the Hamas as “human animals.” Such demonization does not just express our anger and hatred, it validates it, freeing us to retaliate in kind. It allows us to feel superior to the one we view as our enemy.

As with our experience of 9/11, a retaliatory eye-for-an-eye reaction is at play. Israel has declared war against Hamas with the stated objective of wiping them off the face of the earth—not unlike what Hitler sought to do with the Jewish people in the Holocaust. Their objective moves beyond the biblically based eye-for-an-eye retaliation. It reverts back to the practice of unlimited retaliation (Genesis 4:23-24) which the eye-for-an-eye law was designed to replace.

As with our experience of 9/11, we fail to acknowledge that unlimited retaliation—even eye-for-an-eye retaliation—breeds more retaliation. It keeps the cycle of retaliation whirling in constant motion.

Again, as with our experience of 9/11, our anger, hatred, and desire for revenge blinds us to ourselves. We fail to recognize that when we retaliate, we do to “them” what “they” did to us. We become like those we demonize as our enemy. We become the mirror image of those we hate. In condemning and attacking the ugly underbelly of our enemy, we fail to see that our own ugly underbelly is exposed.

Jesus addressed this recurring human pattern in multiple ways.

Jesus taught “do not judge” (Matthew 7:1, Luke 6:37) and “do not condemn” (Luke 6:37). He spoke of judging and condemning another as focusing on the speck in the other’s eye while being blind to the log in your own eye (Matthew 7:3-5). His teaching reinforces the truth that focusing on the other blinds us to ourselves. Judging another is an unconscious effort to avoid seeing what we do not want to see in ourselves—in the language I’m using in this blog, our ugly underbelly. Jesus called us to deal with the log in our own eye—those things about ourselves that we don’t want to see or acknowledge, those things we don’t want to believe we are capable of doing, those things that express our ugly underbelly.  

Dealing with the log in our own eye does two things. It positions us to understand and help the other with the speck in their eye—“then you will see clearly to take the speck out of your neighbor’s eye” (Matthew 7:5). It moves us beyond judging and condemning to understanding and compassion. We can never help another from a posture of judging and condemning. Helping another requires understanding and compassion.

Moving beyond judging and condemning to understanding and compassion is the first step, but not the last. Jesus also taught nonretaliation.

The nonretaliation Jesus taught and practiced was not a passive, let-them-run-over-you response. His language of “turn the other cheek” and “go the second mile” (Matthew 5:38-41) taught nonviolent resistance. The nonviolent response was intended to expose the abuse of power by people in positions of authority and the unfairness of the system that perpetuated the abuse. The nonviolent resistance Jesus taught called for a sense of personal power and dignity that would not react to the indignity embodied in the abuse. It called for personal strength to live out of who we are as the people of God and the followers of Jesus. Such strength resists the inclination to react, doing the same kind of thing the other did, becoming like the other.

Jesus taught a third principle. He taught “love your enemies” (Matthew 5:44, Luke 6:27), that is, “do good to those who hate you, bless those who curse you, pray for those who abuse you” (Luke 6:27). Even more, using the language of unlimited retaliation, he taught unlimited forgiveness (Matthew 18:21-22). He taught us to live as children of our heavenly Father, loving as he loved (Matthew 5:43-48).

Living the ways that Jesus taught is only possible through the power of the Spirit at work in our hearts and minds. Foundational to being able to love our enemies is acknowledging the ugly underbelly we seek to deny—the proverbial log in our own eye. As long as we deny its reality, pushing it out of our awareness, it lurks in the shadows (what Jung called “the shadow”). It wields power in our lives, shaping how we view others. Its presence is seen in our judging and condemning them. Its power is broken when we name the log in our own eye. Acknowledging our anger, bitterness, hatred, and desire for revenge—our ugly underbelly —allows the Spirit to cleanse what is in our hearts. (The old fashion word for this acknowledging of our ugly underbelly is “confession.”) Acknowledging it positions us to see the other with different eyes. It positions us to respond to the other with understanding and compassion. It positions us to love as Jesus loved. It positions us to be a part of ending the seemingly never-ending cycle of eye-for-an-eye retaliation. It allows us to escape the power of our ugly underbelly.  

 

Sunday, October 8, 2023

More than Sinners Saved by Grace

It’s a not-so-subtle theme in most worship services. Preachers commonly attack it in their sermons—if not explicitly, then implicitly. In traditional liturgical worship, we confess it as a reality in our lives. Even our affirmation and praise of God’s grace and forgiveness are painted against this backdrop.

This pervasive theme is sin. Our religious training has taught us to think of ourselves as sinners. We readily declare “I’m just a sinner saved by grace.”

Indeed, all of us fall short—the original meaning of the word sin. Falling short, not measuring up is a normal part of our human condition. None of us are full grown, emotionally-relationally-spiritually mature. We are still in process, learning and growing and changing (hopefully) in pursuit of ever-increasing maturity.

In addition, there is within us an independent spirit that trusts our own thinking over someone in authority, that follows our own way rather than that which has been prescribed for us. That independent spirit translates into a self-focused, self-serving, what’s-in-it-for-me spirit. This reality is reflected in the story of the garden in Genesis 3. In interpreting this story, we commonly speak of sin even though the word sin is not used in the story itself. The word sin is first used in the next story—the story of Cain and his brother Abel. The garden story is based upon our ability to choose—what we call free will—represented in the tree of knowledge. The story teaches us that choices have consequences. It also reflects that we, like the couple in the garden, struggle to live in faithful obedience to, in glad dependency upon God.

These realities—falling short, trusting our own thinking, following our own way, not living in faithful obedience to God—are defined in religious life as sin. Guilt, condemnation, and the fear of judgment are tied to these realities. These realities feed the shame-based identity at the core of our being. (See again the last two blogs.)

The apostle Paul goes beyond speaking of sin as behavior to speak of it as a power that controls us. He spoke of being a slave to sin (Romans 7:14). Paul also wrote that Jesus, in his death and resurrection, broke the power of sin and death (Romans 8:2). In him, we have been set free from condemnation and the fear of judgment. “There is therefore now no condemnation for those who are in Christ Jesus” (Romans 8:1). Through the indwelling Spirit, our hearts and minds are transformed. The self-focused, self-serving, what’s-in-it-for-me spirit is overcome through the transforming work of the Spirit. A Christlike servant spirit is engrained in its place.

All of this, of course, is the work of God through Christ Jesus and the Spirit. It is an expression of God’s steadfast, faithful love that never waivers, that never gives up on us or abandons us. It is a gift of grace. As the writer of Ephesians said, “for by grace you have been saved through faith; it is the gift of God, not the result of works” (Ephesians 2:8-9).

Sadly, many of us who have opened our lives to this grace and the transforming work of the Spirit continue to live out of a sin-based identity. “I’m just a sinner saved by grace.” We continue to let sin define us. Our focus continues to be on how we fall short and on our struggle of trying harder to do better. We fail to claim our identity in Christ as a beloved child of God. We fail to recognize, much less live into and out of, our identity in Christ.

Is “a sinner saved by grace” all there is to us?

The scriptures bear witness to our dignity and worth as the children of God and the followers of Jesus. Consider what the scriptures teach in addition to defining our sin.

·       We were created by God. “For it was you who formed my inward parts; you knit me together in my mother’s womb. I praise you, for I am fearfully and wonderfully made. Wonderful are your works; that I know very well. My frame was not hidden from you, when I was being made in secret, intricately woven in the depths of the earth. Your eyes beheld my unformed substance,” (Psalm 139:13—16a).

·       We were created by God, in the image of God. “So God created humankind in his image, in the image of God he created them; male and female he created them,” (Genesis 1:27). “In the image of God” suggests we were created for relationship with God. A Divine Spark was planted within each of us so that we might participate in and share God’s life of love.

·       Because we are God’s creation, we along with all of creation are innately “good,” not sinful or evil. “God saw everything that he had made, and indeed, it was very good” (Genesis 1:31).  

·       We have been claimed by God in Christ Jesus as God’s beloved children. “See what love the Father has given us, that we should be called children of God; and that is what we are. Beloved, we are God’s children now” (1 John 3:1—2a. Also see Ephesians 1:3-5, Romans 8:14-17, Galatians 4:4-7).

·       We have been called to be the followers of Jesus, learning and living the ways of God Jesus taught and lived (the ways of the Kingdom). 

·       The Spirit of God dwells in us. “And I will ask the Father, and he will give you another Advocate, to be with you forever. This is the Spirit of truth, whom the world cannot receive, because it neither sees him nor knows him. You know him, because he abides with you, and he will be in you” (John 14:16—17).

·       God’s Spirit is at work in us, recreating us into the likeness of Jesus. “And all of us … are being transformed into the same image from one degree of glory to another; for this comes from the Lord, the Spirit” (2 Corinthians 3:18).  “Beloved, we are God’s children now; what we will be has not yet been revealed. What we do know is this: when he is revealed, we will be like him, for we will see him as he is” (1 John 3:2).

·       God’s Spirit has given each of us special gifts and abilities to use in ministry to others. “To each is given the manifestation of the Spirit for the common good. All these are activated by one and the same Spirit, who allots to each one individually just as the Spirit chooses” (1 Corinthians 12:7, 11).   

·       God’s Spirit empowers us to live the ways of God, using our gifts to make a difference in the life of another in Jesus’ name. “You will receive power when the Holy Spirit has come upon you” (Acts 1:8).

·       As the children of God and the followers of Jesus, equipped with the Spirit’s gifts and power, we are God’s partners in the world, doing God’s work in the world. “Very truly, I tell you, the one who believes in me will also do the works that I do and, in fact, will do greater works than these” (John 14:12). (These ten characteristics are from Chapter 14 in my book Discovering Your True Self: A Guide for the Journey.)

A Christ-based, Christ-shaped identity moves us beyond our sin-based identity along with the shame-based identity it perpetuates. It frees us to live as beloved children of God, learning, growing in, and living the ways of God that Jesus taught. It frees us to deal differently with our natural human limitations in which we fall short. Claiming God’s gift of forgiveness, we deal honestly with how we fail so that we can learn and grow from the experiences. We break free from the toxic power of guilt, shame, and the fear of judgment. Living out of a Christ-shaped identity, we deal differently with our struggle to live the ways of God. We learn to live in glad dependency upon God, trusting the Spirit’s power to do what we cannot do in our own strength (2 Corinthians 12:8-10). A Christ-based identity frees us to live out of our gifts, using them to make a difference in the life of another in the name of Jesus. It allows us to live as God’s partners, bringing the kingdom to reality on earth as it is in heaven.

Thanks to the grace of God, we are more than sinners saved by grace. We are beloved children of God. We are the followers of Jesus who are learning and living the ways of God he taught. We are God’s partners who are led by the Spirit to love as Jesus loved.

Sunday, October 1, 2023

Breaking Free from the Toxic Power of Shame

It lies beneath the surface of our awareness, carefully hidden and ignored. We push it outside our awareness so we don’t have to deal with the pain it causes. In spite of our efforts to pretend it doesn’t exist, it is very much alive in the depths of our being, wielding its sinister, destructive power. Ironically, it is our efforts to deny it that gives it its power.

Once again, I am talking about the issue of shame.

Guilt and shame were the focus of last week’s blog (“Dealing with the Toxic Power of Shame,” September 24, 2023). In that blog, I dealt with the shame-based messages that create a shame-based identity at the core of our being: “You are no good—flawed—worthless. You’ll never amount to anything.” After identifying some of the ways we attempt to avoid this deep-seated message and the pain it causes, I ended the blog with a question: How does the message of Jesus address and resolve these shame-based messages and our shame-based identities?

Does the good news Jesus proclaimed have the power to set us free from our shame-based identities? Can it heal the emotional wound that we carry deep in our being? Can it set us free from the emotional pain with which we live? Can Jesus heal our shame?

The scriptures clearly address the issue of guilt.

Guilt is the emotional pain we experience whenever we fail to measure up to the demands of some societal, moral, or religious code. Guilt is about wrong behavior—what in church life is called sin.

Forgiveness is the way to resolve guilt.

Forgiveness is the way God deals with our failure to measure up, i.e., with our sin. It is a gift freely given. God forgives freely, unconditionally, lavishly, even joyfully. Before we ever recognize our sin—much less acknowledge it, confess it, or repent of it—God forgives our sin. God does not judge or condemn us. God forgives—period, end of story.

We have a difficult time dealing with the unconditional nature of God’s forgiveness. Because we naturally live out of merit-based, deserving-oriented thinking, we want to put conditions on God’s forgiveness. “God will forgive us if we confess our sins. God will forgive us when we repent.” In this way of thinking, God’s forgiveness is conditional. We have to do something before God will forgive us. In this way of thinking, forgiveness is no longer a gift. It is a bartered exchange.

How God relates to us is not determined by what we do—i.e., confess and repent of our sins. Rather, God relates to us out of God’s steadfast, faithful love. God relates to us out of grace—out of love that is unconditional. Forgiveness is the primary way God’s grace is expressed. I would go so far as to say God delights in forgiving. It reflects who God is at the core of God’s being. It expresses the heart of God.

Forgiveness—claimed and accepted—heals the pain of guilt. It sets us free from self-condemnation. It positions us to learn from our failure. It allows us to grow through our experience of sin.

While forgiveness is God’s cure for guilt, it—by itself—is not the cure for shame. It contributes to the healing of shame, but something more than forgiveness is needed to set us free from the toxic power of shame.

As I said in last week’s blog, shame stirs on a much deeper level than guilt. Guilt is about wrong behavior. Shame is about who we are at the core of our being. Thus, it operates and resides in the depths of our being. In our formative years, shame was used to condemn our wrong behavior. Those shaming experiences trained us to think of ourselves as no good—flawed—worthless—as someone who cannot measure up—as someone who will never amount to anything. Our experiences of shame inflicted a deep-seated emotional wound—a shame-based identity that governs how we live.

Because of the depth of this emotional wound, we need an experience of grace that pierces to the depths of our being. We need an experience of God’s love that will reshape our sense of who we are at the core of our being.

Forgiveness is a vital part of this healing.

Our wrong behavior often triggers our sense of shame. We use it as evidence that we are indeed no good—flawed—worthless—someone who cannot measure up—someone who will never amount to anything. We view our sin as validation of our shame-based identity. To escape this self-condemnation—which reinforces our shame-based sense of self—we must learn a different way of dealing with our failure to measure up. That different way is embracing God’s way of dealing with our sin. We claim God’s forgiveness.

Forgiveness heals our guilt and relieves its pain. In addition, it defangs our habit of self-condemnation. It breaks the cycle of using our failures to reinforce our shame-based identity. It opens the door to developing a new, different identity—one rooted in God’s unconditional love.

When we experience forgiveness, we experience God’s unconditional love. We are exposed to a different way of thinking and relating—God’s way of unconditional love and grace. Our experience of forgiveness plants the seed that we are loved—deeply, unconditionally, just as we are, with all our weaknesses, failures, and sins. The Spirit nurtures that understanding, helping it take root and grow in our deep mind. (Experiencing forgiveness and/or unconditional love from another person translates the concept of unconditional love into personal experience, making it more believable.) Over time, the seed bears fruit. The Spirit leads us to a new, Spirit-shaped identity as a beloved child of God (Romans 8:14-16, Galatians 4:4-7, Ephesians 1:3-5, 1 John 3:1-3). A beloved child of God—claimed by God’s grace in Christ Jesus—is who the Spirit says we are. That’s who we are.

As with forgiveness, we have to claim this spiritual truth, embracing it as a reality in our lives. As we learn to live out of this reality, the toxic power of the shame-based identity is broken. The emotional wound begins to heal. We move beyond how the world trained us to think about ourselves (Romans 12:2). We claim our identity in Christ Jesus—a beloved child of God.

God’s forgiveness is the cure for our guilt. God’s unconditional love is the cure for our shame.

 

Sunday, September 24, 2023

Dealing with the Toxic Power of Shame

It’s a part of my heritage that rears its ugly head on occasion. It is still a factor in my life—often an unrecognized factor. In spite of all the work I’ve done to overcome how it has shaped my life, it can still blindside me, knocking me off balance.

Truth be told, it can be found in the heritage that came down to each of us. It is, after all, embedded in our culture. Yet, for most of us, it’s an unrecognized, unacknowledged reality of life. Unrecognized means it is unaddressed. Unaddressed means it still wields power in our lives outside of our awareness.

This sinister power is called shame.

Shame is commonly linked with guilt as in the phrase “guilt and shame.” There is, however, a significant difference in the two.

Guilt is the sense of wrong associated with behavior. It stirs inside us whenever we violate some societal, moral, religious, or legal code. Guilt is the emotional pain we feel that calls us to recognize, acknowledge, and address the violation. Its purpose is not to condemn—although it is frequently used to do so, especially in religious circles. Rather, it calls us to right the wrong—to change the wrong behavior so that we conform to the code that was violated.

Shame operates on a much deeper level. Whereas guilt is about behavior, shame is about who we are at the core of our being. It is about our identity—how we think about ourselves. Shame is the message that we are fundamentally flawed and no good. Its intent is to defeat us by telling us we are incapable of measuring up and never will.

Guilt and shame are commonly linked together because our wrong behavior—our failure to measure up to the societal, moral, religious, or legal code—triggers shame’s message that we are no good. Our conscience uses our failure against us, using it as evidence that we are a flawed person who will never measure up. We are judged—by our own selves—as no good. Deep in the core of our being, we live with the belief that we are worthless. We have no real value.

This internal battle which we wage against ourselves is fueled by our shame-based culture. Our society operates on accepted codes of behavior—cultural, moral, religious, legal. We are judged by how we conform to these established, unquestioned codes. The problem does not lie in the codes themselves. The problem lies in how we deal with the inevitable violation of the codes.

Ideally, the failure to live up to an established code calls us to address the behavior. It is an opportunity to teach and train—a proverbial learning opportunity. It invites us to explore what prompted the behavior so we can address the cause, not just the symptom (the behavior). This way of dealing with wrong behavior requires time, patience, curiosity, self-awareness and self-management, compassion and understanding, interest in the person who is in the wrong. It places a greater priority on the person who is in the wrong—particularly his/her growth and maturity—than on his/her conformity to the societal code.

Not surprisingly, our society has taken the easy way out in dealing with wrong behavior. We use shame to address the wrong, using it to motivate the person to try harder to do better. We shame the behavior and the person who did it. This pattern frequently begins in our families but is reinforced throughout our communities—in our schools, churches, social groups, and friendship circles. Growing up, how often were we told “Shame on you!” (I’ve heard this statement in a worship service!) This shame-based way of confronting wrong behavior had the unintended result—hopefully it was unintended—of communicating “you are no good, worthless. You’ll never amount to anything.” We unconsciously internalize this message, using it to shame ourselves. Until we recognize and address this shame-based message and the deep-seated shame from which it comes, we live out of a shame-based identity. “You are no good—worthless. You’ll never amount to anything.”

How do we deal with this toxic message that is rooted deep in our psyche? Why does it lie outside our awareness, wielding its power?

Any number of reasons contribute to our lack of awareness of this shame-based message and our shame-based identity. A primary reason is we have worked hard to avoid the pain this message causes. Avoiding is how we have dealt with the toxic message of shame.

Many of us have become strict enforcers of a particular code, advocating its importance, doubling down on our efforts to conform to it, attacking those who violate it. (Think of those who function as the moral and religious policemen in our society. They are generally rigid, black-and-white thinkers who wear their conservative identity with pride.) Our conformity allows us to avoid the shame-based message spawned by any violation of the code. At the same time, it also blinds us to ourselves, particularly to our attitudes and spirit—the internal realm which Jesus identified as the real source of our wrongdoings (Mark 7:14-19).

Others of us run from the old message by seeking to achieve and succeed. We attempt to offset the shame-based message, using our achievements to refute the deep-seated message that we will never amount to anything because we are, at the core of our being, no good. This strategy plays well in our success-oriented society. This strategy, however, carries numerous downsides. Those of us who embrace this strategy live with a deep fear of failure. We avoid it like the plague. We hide our weaknesses, not just from others, but from ourselves as well. Our identity becomes tied to our work as the means of our achievements and success. We become workaholics. We live out of a persona designed to elicit admiration and praise from others. We feed off of attention, recognition, and applause.  

A strategy all of us use to avoid our internalized, shame-based message is judging and condemning others. This common human trait is based upon comparing and competing. Whenever we condemn another for how they have failed, we not-so-subtly imply that we are better than them. Focusing on the other’s wrongdoing keeps the focus off our own weaknesses, struggles, and failures. I believe this strategy explains our society’s use of shame to address wrong behavior. Condemning and shaming another person allows us to support our own fragile identity by saying “I’m not like them. I’m better than them.” In doing so, we boost ourselves at the other’s expense.

Of course, there are some who surrender to this shame-based message. They live out of a no good, never-amount-to-anything identity. They under-function in life, never developing or living up to their potential. They live in dependency upon another—generally a spouse who enables their under-functioning. Many of them numb out their pain with addiction to alcohol, pot, drugs, sports, hunting-fishing, entertainment, shopping-spending-buying, etc.—or a combination of these escape mechanisms. (I’m reminded of a family member who said to me, as he reached for a beer, “I’m just an old drunk.”) Could it be that Christianity’s focus on sin, confession, and repentance is just a religious version of this pattern?

How does the message of Jesus address and resolve this shame-based message and our shame-based identities? That’s the focus of next week’s blog. 

Sunday, September 17, 2023

When, Not If, We Fail

It’s another thing we all do. It’s an inherent, unavoidable part of our human condition. No one is exempt.

We fail.

Failure is a part of being human.

Any number of factors—all dimensions of being human—can cause us to fail. We don’t have the knowledge to do what is demanded or the training or the skill or the experience or the strength at the moment. Sometimes we fail because of a lack of interest or motivation, a lack of aptitude or self-confidence, a lack of focus or energy.

Because we are human, we are always in process. We are always facing dimensions of life that are new. Each stage of life brings its own set of experiences which are different from those of the previous stage. These new experiences often translate into challenges—things we are having to learn to do as we do them. As a result, we sometimes—often—fail at doing this thing we’ve never done before. Think about a toddler learning to walk.

Because we are human, we live with limitations. We do not have a limitless capacity of anything. We run out of energy and have to refuel. When we are physically or emotionally or intellectually tired, that is, when our energies are low, we struggle to do what we can normally do with ease. As we struggle, we fail.

Relationships often are the most challenging dimension of life. Inevitably, the emotional needs and expectations found in any relationship lead to failures that cause pain for ourselves and others.

Failure is a part of our relationship with God. We call it sin, an archery term meaning to miss the bullseye. It means we fall short. We fail to measure up. We fail to live the ways of God. This failure is commonly viewed as an act of the will—a choice to follow our own way rather than God’s, to trust our own wisdom rather than the wisdom of God, to disobey God’s directives rather than obey them. Again, we all do it. According to Genesis 2 & 3, it is part of our human story.

Because we are human, failure is inevitable, an unavoidable reality with which we must deal.

The problem we face is not that we fail. The problem lies in how we deal with failure.

In our production-driven, success-oriented culture, failure carries a stigma. It is viewed as an indicator of inadequacy, of weakness, of inability to measure up. It translates into being less than or no good. In short, the way we have been trained to deal with failure is with judgment and condemnation, with guilt and shame. We have been trained to shame ourselves for our failure—particularly for our sins.

Because of this shaming, we avoid any appearance of failure. We create a persona that hides our weaknesses or any sense of inadequacy. We seldom let anyone get close enough to know our struggles, much less our failures. We certainly don’t let anyone else know our sins. We often blind ourselves to them—particularly the sins of a critical spirit and judgmental attitude.

How we have been trained to deal with failure produces isolated, lonely lives filled with superficiality. To compensate for the isolation and loneliness, we fill our lives with busyness. To compensate for the superficiality, we pursue status symbols that communicate success. We carry around what Jung called our shadow—those disowned parts of our lives that we view as unacceptable and shameful, that we don’t want others to know.

The way we have been trained to deal with our failure, coupled with our fear of it, has blocked our ability to embrace the way God deals with our humanness, including our failures and sins. God relates to us out of grace. That grace is expressed in the forgiveness of our sins.

God’s grace and forgiveness offer us a different way of viewing and dealing with failure. They treat failure as a normal part of life. Even sins are an expected reality.

The psalmist expressed this understanding: “(The LORD) does not deal with us according to our sins, nor repay us according to our iniquities,” Psalm 103:10. Because the LORD relates to us out of steadfast, faithful love, God forgives our sins, Psalm 103:11. “As far as the east is from the west, so far he removes our transgressions from us. As a father has compassion for his children, so the LORD has compassion for those who fear him. For he knows how we are made; he remembers that we are dust,” Psalm 103:12-14. God recognizes our in-process, not-yet-mature nature.

God’s grace and forgiveness free us to honestly face our failures, including our sins, rather than hiding them. They allow us to accept the in-process nature of our humanness without shaming it. They grant us the opportunity to learn from our failures and, yes, from our sins. That learning leads to growth. God’s grace and forgiveness remind us that God’s desire for us is emotional-relational-spiritual maturity, not our culture’s demand for productivity and success. As we grow, as we mature, we will naturally live out of our gifts and strengths. We will contribute to the good of others—the kingdom’s definition of productivity and success.  

We readily speak of the grace of God, but we struggle to live out of it. We don’t like to fail.

Sunday, September 10, 2023

The Voices in My Head - Discerning the Voice of God

We all have them—these voices in our heads. Not only do we all have them, we all generally listen to them, allowing them to shape our mood in the moment if not our outlook and disposition on life.

Which raises a question: do we ever think to challenge them? Do we ever think to reject what these voices say?

To ask the question a different way: how do we discern the voice of God in our minds (spirit)?

My question is based upon several assumptions.

The first assumption is the Spirit of God speaks to us. The role of the Spirit is to teach us spiritual truth (John 14:25-26; 16:12-15; 1 Corinthians 2:10-16). The Spirit’s role is to guide us in living out that truth (Romans 8:14; Galatians 5:16-18, 25).

This first assumption naturally leads to the next. We can discern the Spirit’s guidance. We can recognize the voice of God speaking to us through the Spirit. Because God speaks to us through the Spirit, we do not normally hear an actual voice with our ear. (While some claim to have heard such a voice, that has not been my experience.) Rather, we discern a movement in our spirit—in the interior realm of the heart.

This second assumption leads to a third: recognizing the voice of God requires discernment. Discernment involves thinking, reflecting, evaluating, and choosing. The Greek word commonly translated as “discern” carries the idea of cutting through. We cut through the surface of what we hear (the content, the message) to the underlying spirit and intent of the message. Discernment goes beyond the surface to the deeper level of spirit and intent. Discernment calls for intentionality. It generally requires being still in order to sense and reflect on the Spirit’s guidance.

Perhaps the most important assumption is that Jesus is the standard we use to discern the guidance of the Spirit and the voice of God. What the voice of God says to us will always align with what Jesus taught and how Jesus lived. Jesus is the in-the-flesh-embodiment of the character of God. He lived and taught the ways of God. Thus, what the Spirit teaches us and how the Spirit guides us will always align with the life and teachings of Jesus.

These assumptions bring us back to the voices in our heads. The voices in our heads are seldom—if ever—the voice of God. A couple of reasons contribute to my confidence in making this statement.

The voices in our heads are rooted in our formative years. Their messages reflect the training we received from our family and the society in which we grew up. They are the internalized voices of the authority figures who shaped our lives. Their voices continue to tell us what we need to do and be if we want to be accepted and valued. They communicate the expectations of culture, not the ways of God. Thus, they seldom echo the voice of God.

In addition, the messages these voices speak to us invariably communicate condemnation and judgment. They are shame-based and shame-inducing messages. They are about our failure to measure up to or conform to social, moral, or religious expectations. They are about how we didn’t do it right—our behavior.

The voice of God never speaks condemnation, judgment, or shame. John 3:17 explicitly says “God did not send the Son into the world to condemn the world.” The apostle Paul, in Romans 8:1, proclaimed, “There is therefore now no condemnation for those who are in Christ Jesus.” Grace and forgiveness, not condemnation and judgment, are the way God deals with the failures inherent to our human condition.

Condemnation and judgment are the ways of the adversary, the one the Bible calls Satan and the devil. In the Hebrew Scriptures, the being called “Satan” was a member of the heavenly court (Job 1:6-7). His role was to identify how people failed. Although it is commonly translated as a name, the word in the original is a noun with the article “the.” A more accurate translation is “the accuser.” The word carries the idea of adversary or opponent—the one who is against us, the one who accuses us. The Greek word translated as “devil” means “to throw against” as in throwing accusations against another.

Thus, the voices that communicate condemnation and judgment—whether the voices in our head or in our churches or in our culture—reflect the spirit of Satan, not the Spirit of God. Their intent is to shame us into trying harder to do better, through self-effort.

In contrast to these voices, the voice of God—the guidance of the Spirit—will always speak grace and forgiveness. God’s grace and forgiveness free us to face, acknowledge, and deal with how we fail to measure up. They allow us to learn from our failures and thereby to grow from them. The intent underlying the Spirit’s guidance is the transformation of our lives—our growth in Christlikeness. The Spirit always leads us into deep, inner peace—the peace of Christ (John 14:27)—that frees us to love as Jesus loved (Galatians 5:21-22).

So how do we deal with the voices in our heads? We follow the example of Jesus. In the temptation experience in the wilderness (Matthew 4:1-11), Jesus recognized the voice that was speaking to him was not the voice of God. It did not reflect the spirit or the intent of God. What it said went against the teachings of scripture. Consequently, Jesus challenged the voice and rejected its message.

Like Jesus, we recognize the voices, acknowledging the messages they communicate. Rather than letting their messages create our mood in the moment or the outlook of our lives, we allow them to point us back to the grace and forgiveness of God where we find peace. Recognizing them, we turn to God, seeking to discern the guidance of the Spirit.

“Since we live by the Spirit, let us keep in step with the Spirit,” Galatians 5:22 (NIV).

Sunday, September 3, 2023

Where We Go Wrong in Discerning the Will of God

 During the past year, The UMC has splintered as members who identify themselves as conservative have chosen to disaffiliate from The UMC. (Disaffiliation is a fancy term meaning “leave.”)

I use the term “splinter” as it reflects the reality of what has happened. The UMC did not split, as into two opposing groups. It splintered. Those who chose to leave did not all chose to become Global Methodists (the new denomination created by those who spearheaded the conservative position in the conflict). Some became independent. Others associated with other Methodist groups. Others started new Wesleyan coalitions.

The identified issue that has fueled this fifty-year conflict and current division is the place and rights of LGBTQ+ people in the church. Every group involved—those who chose to leave as well as those who chose to remain United Methodist—believes they have discerned the will of God regarding the issue.

Here’s the thing about this conflict and splintering (as well as every other conflict that has resulted in division in the church): they can’t all be right! Both sides cannot have discerned the will of God about this issue. Which of the opposing views accurately reflects the will of God?

The answer depends on who you ask. Each side believes they know the will of God regarding the issue.

This controversy and splintering illustrate where—I believe—we go wrong in seeking to discern the will of God. What we identify as the will of God is determined by the standard we use to consider the issue.

In this controversy—as well as in most religious controversies—those of us involved used two primary standards. Those two standards determined the conclusions we reached. (Read that again.) In choosing to use these two standards, we chose their predetermined conclusion. Ironically, we used these standards without stopping to identify them or discuss if they were the appropriate standards to use. They were merely our default standards—the ones we always use in dealing with such issues.

The first standard we use to determine the will of God is a moral standard.

Moral standards identify what behavior society or some group has identifies as right and wrong, acceptable and unacceptable. They are passed down from one generation to the next, taught by families, schools, churches, and community organizations.

Moral standards are part of the lifeblood of religious groups like churches. They are the means by which church members identify themselves, the means by which they evaluate themselves and others. They are often the basis for acceptance or rejection, for praise or condemnation and judgment. Moral standards are such a natural part of the life of a religious group that they are seldom questioned. They are accepted as “what we believe.”

Moral standards are a simple way to determine the will of God. The will of God is clear—whatever the moral standard identifies as right and acceptable behavior.

The simplicity associated with using moral standards to discern the will of God often masks the problems associated with them.

Moral standards call for black-and-white, right-and-wrong, either-or thinking. They do not allow room for the complexities that are an inherent part of any moral issue—what are commonly called “the gray areas.” (A friend suggested that “prism areas” is a better descriptor than “gray areas.” Prisms refract the light, showing the many spectrums that create the light.) Black-and-white, right-and-wrong, either-or thinking fosters the rigidity associated with a closed mind. This kind of thinking does not allow for questions, exceptions, exploration, learning, or growth.

Moral standards primarily focus on behavior, ignoring the interior realm of the heart. Jesus identified the heart as the real source of moral issues. “For it is from within, from the human heart, that evil intentions come: fornication, theft, murder, adultery, avarice, wickedness, deceit, licentiousness, envy, slander, pride, folly. All these evil things come from within” (Mark 7:17-23). The way to deal with wrong behavior is to address what is in the heart. Moral standards almost universally ignore this reality.

Those choosing to use a moral standard to determine the will of God did not have to discern the will of God. It was predetermined by the moral standard they chose to use.

The second standard that was used to determine the will of God in this controversy was the Bible. People on both (all) sides of the issue quoted the Bible to support their position. Because they could quote the Bible in support of their position, they viewed their position as the “biblical” position and, thus, the will of God.

As with moral standards, using the Bible to identify the will of God creates its own set of problems.

The Bible is an ancient book (actually, a compilation of books), written from a Near Eastern, prescientific perspective. It reflects the understanding of God and the ways of God by numerous individuals. It reflects the work of editors who compiled and refined materials that span a period of twenty-five hundred years. Some materials challenge and refute the understanding offered in other books. (The book of Job, for instance, challenges the theology that runs through the wisdom literature, particularly Proverbs and some of the psalms.) A variety of progressions in understanding can be identified in the Bible.

All of these factors—and more—mean we can’t just quote what the Bible says to support our position. The Bible must be interpreted using the best resources available to us, using our best thinking.

One of the factors in this controversy was how the Bible was viewed and used. Some gave equal weight or authority to every verse of the Bible as though every verse reflected the will of God. They failed to recognize the differing levels of revelation and spiritual understanding that are found in the different parts of the Bible. In doing so, they often exalted the teachings of the Levitical law over the teachings of Jesus. They used the Bible as though it, not Jesus, was the fullest revelation of God and of God’s will.

Using the Bible is an important part of discerning the will of God, but it is not the primary standard to be used.

I believe these standards that were used to determine the will of God regarding the LGBTQ+ issue is where we went astray in seeking to discern the will of God. They allowed us to confuse our will with God's will. A different, more reliable standard is needed.

I believe the character of God and the ways of God that grow out of that character are the standard that we are to use in discerning the will of God. The will of God will always be an expression of and align with the character of God. It will always reflect the ways of God.

Jesus is the in-the-flesh embodiment of the character of God. Jesus lived and taught the ways of God. Thus, the will of God will always reflect and align with the teachings, life, and ministry of Jesus. Jesus—not the Bible, not any moral standard—is the fullest and final revelation of the will of God.

Note that using the character of God and the ways of God alongside the life and teachings of Jesus calls of thinking. Discernment involves thinking—thinking shaped by the character of God and the ways of God, under the guidance of the Spirit.

Reflections from Worship Today

  As I participated in corporate worship today, a question came to me: “does what we do in corporate worship keep us stuck in spiritual imma...