Sunday, October 27, 2019

Law Abiding: Does That Mean Loving?

We humans like rules - rules to govern behavior, rules to govern relationships, rules to govern society, rules to govern business and economics, rules to govern worship, rules to govern our meetings, rules to govern our sports - you get the picture. Rules come in various forms - morals, societal expectations, commandments, laws, tradition, ritual, policy - but they all serve one purpose: to govern what we do.

We use rules as a means of dealing with our default human nature. We have learned through the centuries that rules and laws are needed to curb our self-serving nature. We don't trust our "yes" to be "yes," as Jesus taught. We don't trust the other to do what is right or fair for all. And for good reason! We find a way around the rules for our own advantage - just look at national politics. And we write rules (laws) that are advantageous to us but not to all (think congress). In a nation founded on the principle that "all men are created equal," we still struggle to create a society in which all are, in fact, equal. So we create rules and write laws.

I see a number of problems with our rules. Yes, I agree: we need rules and laws. But they still have limitations. Until we recognize and acknowledge the limitations, we will naively depend on rules and laws without regard to their fairness to all.

The first limitation I identify: rules and laws are about behavior. They cannot change the heart. In fact, rules and laws often harden the heart. All of the civil rights legislation, dating back to the 60's, have not eliminated racism. At best, it only made racism go underground and strengthened it. Consider today's political climate or the mass shootings targeting Hispanics, immigrants, blacks, Jews, Muslims.

Which leads to a second limitation: rules inherently stir resistance. We don't like someone else telling us what to do. Remember the outcry among Evangelical Christians at the Supreme Court ruling regarding gay marriage. (Aside: how does Rob and Don's marriage diminish Etta's and my marriage?)

Rules and laws often foster a false sense of superiority. We use the rules to gauge how good we are and how "bad" others are because they don't follow the rules. This attitude is expressed in the term "law abiding."  Religious folks are especially prone to this kind of thinking. For example, consider how we in The UMC view those who take a different position on LGBTQ issues. People on both sides of the issue are equally guilty of viewing the "other" as wrong and, thereby, "less than."

Then, we use the rules to justify our own position and attack the others' position. People on both sides of the LGBTQ issue say "the Bible says!"

Rules and laws are often used to impose "my" position on others. The rule targets "them," not me.

Each of these limitations (and there are others) has to do with the ego. The ego is about "me" - what I want, what I think, what is in my best interest, what is to my advantage. The ego looks at life through "us-them" lens, identifying those who are different as "other." The ego lives out of  fear of the other. The ego lives out of a scarcity mentality that does not think there is enough for everyone. So, the ego wants to ensure I get my share ... and more! Others are viewed as a threat that will keep me from getting "what is rightfully mine." The ego uses power against the other for personal advantage.

What is needed is a radical change of our basic, self-serving nature, i.e., the ego-based self, what the Bible calls the heart.

How we view and treat others is a reflection of what is on the inside - what is in the heart. We do not need more rules to tell us what to do. The rules can tell us what to do, but cannot give us the power to do it. (Paul makes this point in Romans 8:2-3.) What we need is the Spirit to transform what is deep within us. As this transformation occurs, we will understand and embrace Jesus's position about the Law. He identified the greatest commandment as love: "You shall love the Lord your God with all your heart, and with all your soul, and with all your mind. And a second is like it: You shall love your neighbor as yourself" (Matthew 22:34-40). Jesus' summary of the Law: love God, love neighbor. Paul echoed Jesus in Galatians 5:14 - "For the whole law is summed up in a single commandment, 'You shall love your neighbor as yourself.'" I've heard this truth expressed today in these words: if you have to choose between obeying a law and loving another, choose to love. You are never "in the wrong" when you choose to love.

What we need is love ... and that requires a radical change of heart. No rule or law can make me love, but the Spirit can empower me to do so.

May it be so for those of us who follow Jesus!


Monday, October 21, 2019

Saying Goodbye to Being Christian

I no longer identify myself as a Christian.

Since I was a young teen, I have called myself a Christian. This confession has shaped my life, directed my educational pursuits, and determined my life's vocation. But, in recent years, I no longer identify myself by the term "Christian."

I am a follower of Jesus, a disciple.

The term "Christian," like so many religious terms, has taken on too much baggage. To identify as a Christian automatically leads to the next question: what kind of Christian? What brand? I often find myself having to explain "I am not that kind of Christian." So, instead, I no longer use the term.

Interestingly, the term "Christian" was given to the early followers by outsiders. Those early Jesus followers talked about and patterned their lives after "the Christ." Thus, their neighbors referred to them as Christ-ones, Christians.

But not today. Today, the label "Christian" has been hijacked. Today, the term "Christian" is associated with beliefs and positions on issues rather than with a life patterned after the teachings of Jesus. Jesus' spirit of love has been displaced by rigid positions and condemnation of those who do not agree with those positions. And many of those positions are not who I am or what I believe. Even more, many of those positions do not reflect who Jesus was or what he taught, as I understand it. They do not reflect the spirit of Jesus or express the love of Jesus.

So I am saying goodbye to being "Christian." I have unashamedly worn the label most of my life. But no longer. I don't want to be associated with those who claim to be Christian but do not reflect the spirit or life of Jesus.

I want to be known as a follower of Jesus, a disciple.

Sunday, October 13, 2019

Is God on My Side or Am I on God's Side?

All this talk about "thinking" I've been doing, it seems to me, boils down to a simple either-or option. It is one or the other. It can't be both.

Do I allow God's ways (God's truth, God's thoughts) to shape the way I think OR do I use God (i.e., the Bible, the church) to validate what I believe, that is, how I think?

Throughout human history, we humans have claimed that God is "on our side." In our theological debates, in our stances on moral issues, in our political positions, in our wars - we claim our position is God's position. In other words, to disagree with us is to go against God. Our confidence that God is "on our side" frees us from having to examine what we believe or listen to what others believe. We avoid genuine dialogue opting, instead, to dig in and defend our position while attacking the other's. The inevitable outcome is division and alienation.

This claim - or, should I say "false claim" - is more about us than it is about God. We like to be "right." We like being certain.

This desire for certainty is a part of merit-based thinking. "Being right" is another form of "being good." It reflects our effort to be acceptable to God based on what we do. This "being right" mentality does not know grace and, consequently, does not reflect a spirit of grace.

A key indicator that God's truth and God's ways are shaping our thinking is grace. We live with a spirit of humility as we trust God's grace, knowing our relationship with God is not based on being good or right. We relate to others with grace, expressed in unconditional acceptance and forgiveness. We value people more than rules or laws, relationships more than "being right," reconciliation over division. We understand that living out of grace is what it means to be "right."

Sometimes, when we think we are "right" because God is on our side, we are actually wrong because we haven't gotten on God's side. God's truth and God's ways of grace haven't shaped our thinking ... and it shows in our attitudes toward those with whom we disagree.

Sunday, October 6, 2019

Thinking Theologically, Not Politically

It seems to me, thinking theologically is a lost art today among those who call themselves "Christian". Yet, thinking theologically lies at the heart of what it means to be a follower of Jesus.

Thinking theologically is allowing our understanding of who God is and of God's ways to shape how we think and what we believe. Consequently, the nature of God and the ways of God (the Kingdom) shape what we do and how we live.

The failure to think theologically results in us living out of our old, pre-Christian ways of thinking.  In other words, being a Christian hasn't changed us significantly. We are simply a religious version of our former self. Our lives and lifestyles reflect little significant difference from our previous life ... or from those around us, for that matter.

The lost art of thinking theologically is the by-product of the current focus on beliefs. We can "believe" something - an intellectual exercise - that never touches our heart, much less transforms it. What we believe may even be theologically correct, i.e., orthodox, but it does not translate into practice, i.e., orthopraxy. Doctrines and beliefs seldom transform. The experience of grace does. Beliefs that do not lead us to love as Jesus loved are rooted in faulty thinking, not theological thinking.

The starting place for thinking theologically is the character of God as reflected in the life of Jesus and his teachings of the Kingdom of God! What we believe is to be shaped by the character of God and Jesus' teachings of the Kingdom. Note: The starting place for thinking theologically is not the Bible ... and certainly not what we believe! Thinking from the perspective of the character of God and the ways of God (the Kingdom) moves us beyond using the Bible to defend our beliefs, i.e., "The Bible says ..."

Today's political climate is evidence of this lost art of thinking theologically. It seems to me that many of those who call themselves "Christian" today think more in political terms than theological terms. For example, I have been called a liberal preacher. "Liberal" is a political term that people use when they do not agree with what I (or other so-called liberal preachers) proclaim. Calling me or others "liberal" is a way of dismissing what we teach without engaging in dialogue and theological thinking. It is a way to avoid examining what they believe in light of the teachings of Jesus. Their belief, not the teachings of Jesus, become the standard of what is right or wrong.

Thinking theologically is rooted in a teachable spirit. It expresses a humility that knows there is always more to God and God's truth than what I know.  It is part of a commitment to grow in one's understanding of the ways of God and, thereby, in Christ's likeness.

How we think governs how we live. The Spirit of God challenged and changed the thinking of Peter, Paul, and the early church in Jerusalem. That change in what they believed resulted in a change in how they lived. They moved from being in step with their culture - a religious culture, at that! - to being out of step with their culture but in step with the ways of God.

It seems to me that thinking theologically is a vital part of being a faithful follower of Jesus.

But, then, this blog about thinking theologically may just be my liberal thinking!

Or is it?


Sunday, September 29, 2019

God's Plumb Line


The prophet Amos based one of his "sermons" on the image of a plumb line (see Amos 7:7-9). A plumb line was an ancient construction tool used in building stone walls - of a house, of a wall around the city - to insure the wall was perpendicular to the ground. A wall that was not properly aligned was at risk of deterioration, crumbing, and collapsing. 

Amos used the image to communicate to the people of Israel that their lifestyle was "out of alignment" with the ways of God. Their out-of-alignment lifestyle put their nation at risk.

Could we benefit from using God's plumb line in the issues facing the church today? to check the alignment of our thinking and beliefs? How does what we think-believe align with ...

  • the character of God - God's merciful and gracious nature, God's nature of self-giving, servant love
  • the life, ministry, and teachings of Jesus as a reflection of God's character
  • grace and forgiveness, the way God relates to us
  • the ways of the Kingdom that Jesus taught and lived: all are beloved children of God, relationships are based on grace and forgiveness (rather than merit), power is used to serve, material wealth and possessions are a form of power to be used on behalf of the powerless
  • the transformation of heart and mind that we call spiritual growth (as opposed to a focus on proper belief and behavior)
  • loving as Jesus loved. 

Note that I do not speak of the Bible as God's plumb line, although many Christians do. "What does the Bible say?" is their mantra. They use the Bible to validate their beliefs. This practice is being used  by some in The UMC today to validate their position on LBGTQ issues, forgetting how the Bible was once used to support slavery and to deny women voice and leadership in the church. It's not enough to appeal to the Bible. The better test is "Does it align with the character of God?"

At the end of a plumb line is some kind of weight that, because of gravity, sets the line taunt and straight. It is what makes the plumb line functional. That "weight" in God's plumb line is the character of God.

Does what I think and how I believe align with who God is?











Monday, September 23, 2019

What Do You Think

What do you think? Or, rather, how do you think?

The Apostle Paul frequently wrote about "the renewing of the mind" (Romans 12:2; Ephesians 4:22-24). He exhorted the Philippians to "put on the mind of Christ" (Philippians 2:5-11). "Set your mind on" says the letter to the Colossians (Colossians 3:2).

For Paul, the renewing of the mind - the transformation in how/what we think - was the heart of the spiritual transformation process. Learning the ways of God is foundational to spiritual development.

The renewing of the mind has two dimensions: (1) unlearning the old way of thinking as we (2) learn the ways of God that Jesus taught.

In Romans 12:2, Paul wrote "stop being conformed to the pattern of this world" (personal translation). His thought: we have been trained to think by the values of the world in which we live. We naturally think from that perspective. It is how we think. It is what we think. Until we recognize and identify this way of thinking, we will unconsciously live out of it. It governs what we do.

This unlearning occurs as we "put on the mind of Christ," that is, as we learn the ways of God that Jesus taught. This learning a different way of thinking is the work of the Spirit in our lives (John 14:26). (See Acts 10 for a record of this Spirit-led shift of thinking in the life of Peter.)

These two ways of thinking are at odds with one another. "For my thoughts are not your thoughts, nor are your ways my ways, says the LORD" (Isaiah 55:8).
  • We have been trained to think in terms of us-them. The ways of God embrace all as beloved children of God. All are embraced and included. 
  • We have been trained to think in terms of merit, judging the other according to how they measure up to our thinking and expectations. As a result, we barter acceptance in exchange for conformity. We dole out condemnation and rejection to those who fail to conform. The ways of God teach us to relate out of grace and forgiveness, the way God relates to us. 
  • We have been trained to use our power against others, for our own benefit. The ways of God call us to use our power to serve others, addressing their need and fostering their development. 
  • We have been trained to use material possessions as a status symbol and as the basis of our sense of security. Consequently, we amass things and never have enough. We always want "more." The ways of God lead us to use our material possessions on behalf of others, particularly the poor and those who have little. 
  • We have been trained to think from the perspective of scarcity - there's not enough for everyone. Consequently, we make sure we have "ours". The ways of God teach us to think from the perspective of abundance rooted in God's faithfulness, goodness, and provision. 
These two ways of thinking and living are diametrically opposed to one another.

Part of the challenge in this renewing of the mind is an internal resistance to changing the way we think. (See Matthew 16:21-22 for an example of this resistance in Peter's life.) We function as though what we think is "right." Our sense of identity is tied to being "right." Thus, we are resistant to looking at a different way of thinking. We automatically reject anything that challenges what and how we think. We look for that which confirms what we think. (This unconscious process is so common that social scientists have given it a name: confirmation bias.) We attack those who think differently, calling them "liberal" or "right wing." These labels are our way of dismissing the other as "wrong" while reassuring ourselves that we are "right."

This internal resistance affects the way we read the Bible. Our inclination (practice?) is to go to scripture looking for what we already believe and for validation of that belief. Think of how often we appeal to "the Bible says." A better question than "what does the Bible say?" is "does this thinking align with the character and nature of God, with the teachings and ministry of Jesus, with the mind of Christ?" Is it Christ-like? (See my blog: Asking a Better Question, April 1, 2019.)

This reality of an automatic internal resistance to changing the way we think raises the question: how teachable are we? How willing are we to allow the Spirit to challenge and change what we think?

Sunday, September 15, 2019

The True Self

In Ephesians 4, the biblical writer (Paul?) instructed his readers to put off the old self, to put on the new self (Ephesians 4:22-24). The author's image of changing clothes depicts the essence of the spiritual journey. It is a journey of inner transformation and change. The spiritual journey is about the interior life - the condition of the heart.

We live out of what is inside ... out of what is in our heart. The condition of the heart determines what we do and how we relate. As the heart is transformed, what we do and how we relate changes, as well.

Thomas Merton, the Trappist monk and mystic, referred to the new self as the true self - the person God originally created us to be and is now recreating us to be. The true self is who we are in Christ.

The true self (new self) has two dimensions: (1) who God created us to be when God knit us together in our mother's womb (Psalm 139:13-14) coupled with (2) how God is recreating us into the likeness of Christ.

The true self includes our uniqueness - who we are that no one else can be. As we grow into our true self, we joyfully live out of our gifts and abilities in an area of passion to make a difference in the life of another in Jesus' name. True self = gifts + passions + ministry in Jesus' name.

The true self is also who we are with a transformed heart. The true self is the product of God's work, of the Spirit's work in our life. The biblical writer said the new self is created to be like God in true righteousness and holiness (vs. 24). The true self reflects the likeness of God, the character of God. The true self is who we are as we mature spiritually.

Thus, the true self exhibits the fruit of the Spirit. The true self lives out of joy and peace. The true self chooses to love as Jesus loved.

The new self stands in contrast to the old self. The biblical writer described the old self as "corrupt and deluded by its lusts" (vs. 22 - think of "lusts" as hungers). The old self is the self-serving self, the one that lives out of a what's-in-it-for-me spirit. I speak of the old self as the constructed self - the self we created by conforming to the expectations and demands of some social group (family, church, school, friends, community, society.)  The old self or constructed self is who we became in order to gain attention or acceptance or affection or approval from that defining group. (These four - attention, acceptance, approval, affection - are our emotional hungers that unconsciously govern our lives.) In other words, our old self is who they create us to be. (As adults, these original groups give way to a fraternity/sorority, country club, service organization, business associates, etc.)

Our old, constructed self is based upon external conformity to the expectations and social standards of our "homies." Note: it is focused on the externals, not the internal - behavior, not the heart - what we do or don't do, not what is deep inside. Our old, constructed self depends on self-effort, resulting in trying harder to do better. It naturally involves comparing - comparing ourselves to the standard of expectations, comparing ourselves to others. It produces us-them thinking - who is acceptable, who is not; who's in, who's out. It naturally involves competing, leading to better than-less than thinking. It naturally involves judging leading to merit-based thinking. "S/he doesn't deserve ..." "It s/he would only ..., then ..." It naturally involves using power against others, bargaining acceptance and approval for conformity while threatening rejection and condemnation.

This old, constructed self is a fragile self, easily threatened by that which is different and those who are different. We protect it through ridged beliefs and positions. We attack and demonize anyone who does not align with our beliefs and positions.

The old, constructed self cannot love as Jesus loved. It is too busy protecting its fragile veneer. It does not know inner peace or joy. It lives with anxiety and fear, anger and resentment. Love, joy, and peace are only possible as the Spirit transforms our hearts, setting us free to be who God created us to be ... the new self, our true self.

Reflections from Worship Today

  As I participated in corporate worship today, a question came to me: “does what we do in corporate worship keep us stuck in spiritual imma...