Symptoms
are what motivate us to seek the help of a doctor. The doctor, in turn, looks
beyond the symptoms to what is causing them. The doctor seeks to address the
underlying germ or virus or disease that is causing the symptoms. The symptoms
only go away when the root cause has been addressed.
Using
this symptom-disease metaphor, we United Methodists are focused on symptoms without
recognizing or addressing the underlying cause.
The
conflict over how to deal with LGBTQ+ issues is a symptom. It only exists
because of other, underlying issues. Those underlying issues have produced the
conflict over LGBTQ+ issues. Until those underlying issues are identified and
addressed, the issues related to LGBTQ+ individuals will never be resolved.
In
my mind, the primary underlying issue is the interpretation of scripture.
People on both sides of the LGBTQ+ issue value the Christian scriptures as the
source book of faith. Interestingly, the statements about scripture in the Book
of Discipline of the Global Methodist Church and of The United Methodist Church
are identical. The difference lies in how scripture is viewed, interpreted and,
consequently, used.
Most
who identify themselves as traditionalists or conservatives view the Bible as
the Word of God (capital W). For them, it is a divine book. They believe
everything in the Bible reflects God’s truth. (Well, almost everything. There
are some things they don’t accept, such as the stoning of a rebellious son or
of a daughter who is pregnant outside of marriage, but they seldom talk about
those kinds of things.) They read the Bible literally, understanding the Bible
means what it says and says what it means. Reading the Bible literally does not
require interpretation (in their minds). Following this way of reading
scripture, the Book of Discipline of the Global Methodist Church condemns
homosexuality as a sin, identifying it as a chosen sexual perversion. Their
position is based upon what the Bible says. In turn, anyone who does not
identify homosexuality as a sin is viewed as not believing the Bible.
Rather
than reading scripture literally, the traditional United Methodist approach to
interpreting scripture (what is today referred to as progressive) uses
tradition, reason, and experience. It values and relies upon biblical
scholarship. This approach speaks of Jesus rather than the Bible as the Word of
God (capital W – John 1:1-5, 12-14, 16-18). It views the Bible as God’s gift to
us, given through the work of numerous authors and editors. “Long ago God spoke
to our ancestors in many and various ways by the prophets” (Hebrews 1:1). Thus,
the Bible is a human book as well as a divine book. God’s truth comes to us
wrapped in a human wrapper. Identifying divine truth (the task of interpretation)
requires us to identify the human dimensions—historical setting, cultural
setting, theological viewpoint, language issues, etc. We find God’s word for us
today in God’s word to the original audience within its historical and cultural
situation.
This
tradition-reason-experience approach recognizes the different voices in
scripture. Each voice reflects the author’s attempt to understand God and how
to relate to God. The voices often contradict and challenge each other. The challenge
of interpretation is identifying the different voices and determining which
voice best reflects the voice of God. Because Jesus is the fullest revelation
of God—as opposed to the “many and various ways” God spoke in the past (Hebrews
1:1)—this way of interpreting the Bible reads through the lens of Jesus. It “hears”
the voice of God primarily in the life and ministry of Jesus. “In these last
days, God has spoken to us by a son. He is the reflection of God’s glory and
the exact imprint of God’s very being” (Hebrews 1:2, 3). In this way of
interpreting scripture, every verse is not given the same weight of authority
nor does every verse reflect God’s final revelation of truth. That most complete
revelation is found in Jesus.
The
task of interpretation calls us to distinguish between that which reflects the
truth of God and that which reflects the human situation in which that truth
was expressed. Consequently, the task of interpretation calls for our best
thinking. Failure to distinguish between the human dimensions and the divine can
result in viewing time-bound, cultural norms as divine truth. We end up chewing
on the wrapper rather than tasting the sweetness of God’s truth.
The
literal approach to reading scripture appears to be simpler. However, it has
inherent dangers. When we read scripture literally, we open the door to using
the Bible to validate what we already think and believe. We are confident in
our belief because “the Bible says!” That confidence (arrogance?) leads us to
use the Bible as a rule book, identifying right and wrong, righteousness and
sin. From that posture, the Bible can easily be used as a weapon to condemn sin
and the sinner. This use of scripture focuses upon behavior, particularly
sinful behavior. It blocks self-awareness, blinding us to the critical,
judgmental, condemning spirit and arrogant attitude that reside in our hearts. This
process allows us to unconsciously create God in our image. Our way of thinking
and living becomes identified as God’s ways and God’s will. Ultimately, this
process blocks the renewing of the mind that is the catalyst to a cleansed heart
and transformed life (Romans 12:2). We remain essentially unchanged, trapped in
merit-based thinking and living.
In
this literal way of reading and interpreting the Bible, Jesus is seen primarily
as our savior who saves us from our sins and from hell. He is seldom looked to
as the fullest revelation of the character of God and the ways of God. The
focus on sin overshadows his emphasis upon the heart. Repentance becomes a
prerequisite for forgiveness, making forgiveness conditional.
How
we interpret scripture is, in my mind, the primary issue underlying the LGBTQ+
issues. It determines the other underlying issues, as well: the nature of the
Christian life (“A good Christian does … doesn’t”), the nature of the church,
the nature of grace, and, ultimately, the nature of God.
For
those who read scripture literally, the Christian life is expressed in right
belief (orthodoxy), right behavior (morals), and right worship. It is
rule-oriented. For those who view scripture as a human-divine book and
interpret it through the lens of Jesus, the Christian life is expressed in
love, manifested in grace and forgiveness that embraces every person as a beloved
child of God.
For
those who read scripture literally, the church is the guardian of right belief,
right behavior, and right worship. It serves as the moral policeman to society,
condemning and resisting sin (behavioral sins). For those who interpret the
Bible through the lens of Jesus, the church is a spiritual community who offers
the world an alternative way of thinking and living. It embodies the grace and
forgiveness of Jesus, valuing and embracing every person as a beloved child of
God.
Those
who read scripture literally proclaim grace and forgiveness. That grace and
forgiveness is conditional, accessible only through repentance. “If you repent,
God will forgive you.” Those who interpret the Bible through the lens of Jesus
view God’s grace and forgiveness as unconditional. God’s acceptance and
forgiveness are gifts freely given. We respond to these gifts in faith. God’s grace
and forgiveness move us beyond a focus upon sin. They free us from slavery to
guilt, shame, and fear. They free us to love God and others, including those
who are not like us.
When
we recreate God in our image — one of the inevitable results of a literal
reading of scripture — we generally think of God in terms of authority, viewing
him (and in this way of reading, God is always male) as a judge who gives us
what we deserve. When we read scripture through the lens of Jesus, we come to
know God as a God of steadfast, faithful love (Hebrew: chesed) whose love never waivers, who never gives up on us or
abandons us. We come to know God as a God of grace and forgiveness who responds
to us with compassion and mercy.
How
we resolve each of these underlying issues — how to interpret scripture, the
nature of the Christian life, the nature of the church, the nature of grace,
the nature of God — determines our position on the LGBTQ+ issues facing The
UMC. The LGBTQ+ issues are but the symptoms of these deeper, underlying issues.